Five Points Cafe

Located in the heart of Sayville, NY, Five Points Cafe is a lively bar & grill that masterfully blends casual comfort with a diverse and flavorful menu. Whether you're stopping by for a refreshing Mango Margarita or settling in for their renowned Cajun Chicken Sandwich, this vibrant spot promises a satisfying experience from the first sip to the last bite.

The cuisine at Five Points Cafe offers an impressive range of American favorites infused with bold, fresh ingredients that elevate every dish. Their Bacon Cheeseburger and Downtown Burger & Fries are superbly crafted, boasting juicy, perfectly cooked patties paired with crispy fries that are just the right balance of salty and tender. For something a bit more adventurous, the Autumn Pork Burger delivers a seasonal twist that dances on the palate, while the Parmesan Crusted Chicken Sandwich with Mac n Cheese is a comforting indulgence combining crispy crust and creamy decadence. Fans of seafood will find the Grilled Ahi Tuna Salad and Coconut Shrimp dishes delightfully fresh and bursting with flavor.

Five Points Cafe doesn’t stop at solid entrees; their appetizers and desserts are equally enticing. The Spin Chip App has been praised for its deliciousness, and you can't miss the Fudge Brownie Sundae—rich, velvety, and the perfect sweet finale that leaves you wanting more. The kitchen also serves up a tempting French Onion Soup that perfectly balances savory broth with melted cheese.

The bar selection is just as thoughtfully curated, with a fine variety of white wines, including a crisp Pinot Grigio from Veneto, Italy, and a sweet Moscato from Sicily, designed to complement your meal beautifully. Beer lovers will appreciate the range on tap—from the smooth Bud Light to the full-bodied Guinness and seasonal IPAs, all served chilled to quench your thirst. Margaritas here come in vibrant flavors such as Blood Orange, Strawberry, and Coconut, each priced right and mixed to perfection—ideal for unwinding on their shaded outdoor patio, a favorite spot among patrons.

Speaking of atmosphere, Five Points Cafe strikes a perfect balance between lively and relaxed. The outdoor seating is a breath of fresh air, shaded and breezy, making it an excellent choice for casual gatherings or low-key celebrations. Whether it’s for a cozy lunch catching up with family or a spirited evening enjoying Music Bingo as noted by guests, the friendly and attentive staff ensure every visit is a pleasant and memorable one. Reviewers constantly point out the welcoming service, with servers who are knowledgeable and genuinely sweet, creating a warm ambiance that feels like dining with friends.

Five Points Cafe truly feels like a community gem where the food is fresh, the drinks are strong yet reasonably priced, and every detail—from the fluffy, cheese-topped pretzels to the perfectly grilled sandwiches—reflects care and passion. For locals and visitors alike, it’s a place that invites you to savor great flavors while enjoying friendly hospitality in the heart of Sayville.